Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


18 April 2018

A Roman historian told of 'swarthy' Britons

From Shane Jones, Ipswich, Queensland, Australia

Colin Barras reports analysis of Cheddar Man's 10,000-year-old DNA suggesting that he may have had dark skin and blue eyes ( 3 March, p 12 ). In Agricola , 8000 years later, the Roman historian Tacitus divides the inhabitants of Britain into three categories thus: "The reddish hair and large limbs of the Caledonians proclaim …

18 April 2018

Better food for dogs, better food for humans

From Matt Ball, The Good Food Institute, Washington DC, US

It is great that Wild Earth's bioreactor-grown dog food has a lower carbon footprint ( 24 March, p 12 ). But companies such as Beyond Meat in the US and Moving Mountains in the UK are using plants to biomimic meat. This causes much less climate change, among its other advantages. It ensures that all …

25 April 2018

Science education in the UK needs to wake up

From Roger Redman, Moorlinch, Somerset, UK

Your careers special highlights the dramatic challenge Brexit poses to the UK's ability to attract and retain top scientists and engineers from Europe ( 7 April, p 49 ). But what faces young people in the UK who are considering such fields? After a career in aerospace, I have been a " STEM ambassador " …

25 April 2018

If it's intelligent, it will just make stuff up

From Brian Horton, West Launceston, Tasmania, Australia

Timothy Revell discusses whether artificial intelligences should be required to explain their decisions ( 14 April, p 40 ). This seems reasonable until we apply the same rules to humans. When people have to make quick decisions in complex situations they confabulate, making up a plausible reason for a decision even when this has no …

25 April 2018

More idiocy in the internet of things

From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK

I couldn't agree more with Paul Marks on the stupidity of "killer kettles" and other internet of things products ( 24 March, p 24 ). An example that particularly concerns me is the enthusiasm the UK government and energy companies have for installing "smart" meters. These are not smart at all – they can simply …

25 April 2018

How do these 'good' GM crops stack up?

From Rosemary Bentley, Egham, Surrey, UK

Mark Lynas says the genetically modified staple crops he is now advocating "have nothing to do with the corporate behemoths that are the usual targets of suspicion in the GM debate" ( 7 April, p 26 ). But is it possible for poor farmers to harvest seeds to be used the following year? If not, …

25 April 2018

That's an awful lot of water in my pint

From Brian Jones, Melbourne, Australia

You quote Charles Denby saying that it takes 50 litres of water to grow enough hops to make a pint of beer ( 24 March, p 19 ). I am an avid home brewer and use about 200 grams of hops per 40-litre batch – nearly 3 grams per pint. A typical hop plant yields …

25 April 2018

Looking forth over the 'wine-dark' ethane

From Guy Cox, Sydney, Australia

It was great to read that finally someone is thinking outside the box in the search for life ( 24 March, p 40 ). One simple and definitive test for life wasn't mentioned. Complex carbon compounds such as sugars and amino acids typically have two chemically identical forms, called enantiomers, that are mirror images of …

25 April 2018

My head did literally explode, in a sense

From Therese Miner, Potsdam, New York, US

Tom Gauld's cartoon depicts a conversation: "Did you hear about Professor Larson's new theory? It's literally blowing people's minds." "I think you're misusing the word 'literally'." "Sadly, I'm not." (Letters, 20 January). Many of our heads were literally blown a few years ago when dictionaries began to include an additional definition for the word "literally" …

25 April 2018

For the record - 28 April 2018

• In the satire Great Apes , the actors were of course playing apes not monkeys ( 7 April, p 48 ). • It was private investment in renewable energy in the developed countries that has halved since 2011 ( 14 April, p 25 ).

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop