Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


15 May 2024

Are we in a cosmic hole of our own making? (1)

From John Bell, Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire, UK

You report that we are roughly in the centre of a very rare void in the universe that doesn't match our cosmological theories. What else seems to be vanishingly rare in our part of the universe, roughly in the centre of the void? Life. (20 April, p 36) That is either an impressive coincidence or …

15 May 2024

Are we in a cosmic hole of our own making? (2)

From Jane Monroe, Arcata, California, US

Clearly, the reason that the Milky Way is near the centre of a cosmic void is that no other advanced life forms want to risk their worlds getting infected with Earth's planet-destroying virus. They aren't yet sure if it is catching, so they are keeping their distance.

15 May 2024

Just so many sources of pollution to worry about

From Victoria Oswald, San Francisco, California, US

Thank you for the article on indoor climbing walls and the concerns about inhaling chemicals in the rubber dust released by the shoes used in such facilities. It was excellent, and this is something I have worried about for a while. ( 11 May, p 10 ) In a similar vein, I also have concerns …

15 May 2024

Demonising plastic really isn't helpful

From Rich Martin, Melbourne, Australia

The statement that "plastic, rightly demonised as a scourge of the modern world, could be fantastic again" seems to go too far in its criticism of the material. ( 27 April, p 36 ) It takes less energy to make a plastic bottle than a glass one. Additionally, plastic films play a crucial role in …

15 May 2024

Deluges could bring a climate change gain

From Geoff Harding, Sydney, Australia

The increasing frequency of heavy rainfall events in the United Arab Emirates – like the one we saw recently, probably driven to some extent by rapid climate change – may reduce dependence on energy-intensive desalination, which is currently a key source of drinking water in the region. ( 27 April, p 16 ) Interconnected underground …

15 May 2024

Damned if you do, damned if you don't

From Dudley Miles, London, UK

If you eat meat, researcher Anthony Hulbert recommends you have grass-fed beef or lamb and wild-caught fish, as they are high in omega-3s, and avoid pork and chicken because they are high in omega-6s. I rarely eat fish as I don't want to contribute to the destruction of aquatic wildlife, and I avoid beef and …

22 May 2024

The Anthropocene: it is less about the dates

From Matthew Edgeworth, Bedford, UK

Jan Zalasiewicz implies that the mass of evidence of human impact on the Earth system was rejected in the recent vote by geologists over the Anthropocene. Actually, few scientists would dispute that substantial body of evidence. What was rejected was the specific proposal that the start of the Anthropocene epoch should be placed in 1950 …

22 May 2024

Remembering when maths meets real life

From Keith Walters, Sydney, Australia

Katie Steckles's article about "Pythagoras in the wild" reminds me of an interesting experience of encountering maths when buying cake tins. I got two "catering-sized" square ones from a commercial baking supplier. I was intrigued by the dimensions: about 360 millimetres per side. That figure didn't seem to mean anything special. Neither did the equivalent …

22 May 2024

Population decline will put us on slippery slope

From Hubert van Hecke, Santa Fe, New Mexico, US

Several readers have voiced optimism about reaching a new economic equilibrium in a world where each generation is smaller than the previous one ( Letters, 20 April ). However, such an equilibrium would be only temporary. Once the world population falls to, say, half a billion, no one is building a new particle collider or …

22 May 2024

To escape light pollution, try life on the ocean waves

From Butch Dalrymple Smith, La Ciotat, France Chanda Prescod-Weinstein laments the difficulty of seeing the night sky due to modern lighting. There is one group of people who can still appreciate it with no problem: sailors ( 4 May, p 22 ). On the ocean in a sailing yacht you experience the heavens at full …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop